Jude Bellingham’s stature in international football has grown rapidly since his debut as a teenager, with appearances and goals at the 2022 World Cup and Euro 2024 underlining his reputation. However, his role for England has become less consistent since Thomas Tuchel took charge, with the midfielder often excluded from squads and line-ups. Tension seemed to rise further when Tuchel described Bellingham’s behavior as “repulsive” during the summer, a remark he later withdrew.
England’s comfortable win over Albania rounded off an unbeaten qualifying campaign, yet Bellingham showed clear displeasure when replaced near the end. Tuchel responded by stating the matter would be examined and reminded that discipline is vital. The midfielder’s irritation has reignited debate about whether he is simply frustrated or whether there is a deeper issue affecting the dynamic between player and coach.
Competition for the central creative role has intensified. Morgan Rogers, Phil Foden, Eberechi Eze, and Cole Palmer have all enhanced their claims, and Bellingham no longer has a guaranteed spot. Despite his honors in Germany and Spain and consistent domestic form, his usage under Tuchel has dropped sharply, continuing a pattern of irregular involvement before major tournaments.
Former players have offered differing views. Stephen Warnock has argued that selection should be based on form rather than reputation, and that Rogers merits the position for now. Conor Coady believes Bellingham feels pressure to prove himself after missing a recent camp, noting that the midfielder knows he must seize every opportunity.
Debate around attitude and impact
Bellingham’s contribution against Albania and the influence he made off the bench against Serbia have strengthened the belief of some observers that he remains England’s strongest option in attacking midfield. David Walker of The England Pod expects him to start at the World Cup and questions the idea that Bellingham is a disruptive figure. Walker attributes much of the perception to Tuchel’s misjudged choice of words earlier in the year, adding that the midfielder usually presents himself maturely.
While Bellingham occasionally displays visible frustration, he is known for stepping up in decisive moments. This blend of determination and emotion has shaped many of his standout performances for club and country, even if it sometimes creates tension in high-pressure environments.
Under Carlo Ancelotti at Real Madrid, Bellingham thrived in a system that relied on trust and balance within a squad of established personalities. His output since arriving in Spain reflects both responsibility and consistency, with fans appreciating his influence on the pitch and leadership off it.
This season, however, a change in manager has brought a different environment. Xabi Alonso’s methods have been described as demanding, with suggestions in Spain that some players have struggled with the intensity. Although there have been whispers questioning Bellingham’s discipline under the new regime, there is little evidence of this during matches, and some believe the issue may stem from a clash between temperaments.
Tuchel’s history with big personalities
Tuchel’s coaching path has included multiple high-profile disagreements. His animated exchange with Kylian Mbappe at Paris Saint-Germain and his public criticism of Callum Hudson-Odoi during his Chelsea tenure both underline his forthright approach. At Bayern Munich, tension in the dressing room reached the point where Sadio Mane reportedly struck Leroy Sane after being dropped, a situation that developed under Tuchel’s leadership.
Observers note that Tuchel communicates directly and demands full commitment from his squad. This clarity can lead to conflict but also provides structure. With Bellingham’s prominence and profile, even minor incidents naturally attract significant attention.
Nonetheless, some argue that the current situation should not overshadow England’s progress. Walker suggests that if this is the most serious concern facing the team, England may actually be in a strong place compared with previous periods of instability.
